Finding the Best Debt Defense Lawyer in Wisconsin

When a debt collector sues you, they are counting on you to be too confused or intimidated to fight back. They have a system, and they expect you to follow their script. Hiring a lawyer completely changes the dynamic. It signals that you are taking this seriously and are prepared to defend your rights. An experienced attorney knows how to scrutinize the collector's case for weaknesses, from expired statutes of limitations to missing paperwork. This guide will show you how to find the best debt defense lawyer in Wisconsin—an expert who can level the playing field and turn the tables in your favor.

Key Takeaways

• Don't Ignore the Lawsuit; Use the Law to Your Advantage: Responding to a lawsuit is your first and most critical step. A key defense in Wisconsin is the six-year statute of limitations, which can get an old debt case dismissed before it even starts.
• Hire an Expert in Wisconsin Debt Law: Don't settle for a general lawyer. You need an attorney who specializes in consumer protection and understands Wisconsin's specific rules, as this local expertise can be the deciding factor in your case.
• A Lawyer Does More Than Just Fight in Court: Your attorney is also your negotiator and financial protector. They can work to settle your debt for a lower amount, stop wage garnishment, and guide you toward the best financial path forward, often without ever seeing a judge.

What is Debt Defense in Wisconsin?

Getting sued by a creditor is stressful, but you have more power than you think. Debt defense is the set of legal strategies used to protect yourself in a debt collection lawsuit. It means understanding your rights and using the legal process to challenge the claim or negotiate a better outcome. This isn't about just letting things happen to you; it's about taking an active role to ensure your side is heard and your rights are protected every step of the way.

Common Types of Debt Cases

In Wisconsin, collection lawsuits typically involve unsecured debts—meaning the debt isn’t tied to property like your house or car. The most frequent cases stem from overdue credit card bills, medical expenses, personal loans, and balances owed after a car repossession. These are the kinds of debts that collectors often purchase and then pursue aggressively through the court system. If you’re facing a lawsuit, it’s likely related to one of these common debt types. Understanding this can help you and your lawyer prepare the right defense strategy for your specific situation.

Know Your Rights Under Wisconsin Law

You’re not alone in this process, and Wisconsin law offers important protections. One of the most critical is the statute of limitations, which gives creditors a six-year window to sue you from the date of your last payment. If a collector sues you for a debt that’s older than that, the case may be dismissed. State laws also work alongside federal regulations to shield you from unfair or harassing collection tactics. Knowing your consumer rights in Wisconsin is the first step toward building a strong defense.

When Do You Need a Lawyer?

The moment you receive official court papers—usually a Summons and Complaint—is the time to get legal help. While you can represent yourself, the legal system has complex rules and deadlines that are easy to miss. A debt defense lawyer understands this process, from filing the correct response to identifying weaknesses in the collector’s case. Even if you haven’t been sued yet but are dealing with aggressive collectors, hiring an attorney for debt issues can provide clarity and help you understand your options before the situation escalates.

What to Look For in a Debt Defense Lawyer

Finding the right lawyer can feel like a monumental task, especially when you're already stressed about a lawsuit. But choosing your legal partner is one of the most powerful steps you can take to protect yourself. You're not just looking for someone with a law degree; you're looking for an advocate who understands your situation and knows how to fight for you. Think of it as hiring a specialist. You wouldn't see a foot doctor for a heart problem, and you shouldn't hire a general practice lawyer for a specific debt collection issue. Debt collection is a unique area of law with its own set of rules, deadlines, and strategies that a generalist might miss.

The right attorney does more than just file paperwork. They understand the tactics used by debt collectors and know how to counter them. They can spot illegal collection practices, identify weaknesses in the creditor's case, and negotiate from a position of strength. This expertise is what levels the playing field between you and a large collection agency or creditor. Your search should focus on a few critical areas that separate a great debt defense lawyer from the rest: their specific qualifications, deep experience in consumer protection, expert knowledge of Wisconsin law, a history of success, and a clear, supportive communication style. Finding someone who excels in these areas will give you not only the best chance at a positive outcome but also the peace of mind that comes from having a true expert in your corner.

Essential Qualifications and Certifications

First things first, you need to confirm the basics. Any lawyer you consider must be licensed to practice in Wisconsin and in good standing with the state bar. This is non-negotiable. Beyond that, look for signs of specialized training. While debt defense doesn't have formal certification levels like some other legal fields, a lawyer's focus on consumer law is a strong indicator of their expertise. You want an attorney who dedicates their practice to this area, not someone who only handles debt cases occasionally. Ask about their continuing legal education and professional memberships related to consumer rights. This shows they are committed to staying current on the laws that will protect you.

Experience with Consumer Protection

Debt collection is a specific field within the broader area of consumer protection law. You want a lawyer who lives and breathes this stuff. An attorney with a strong background in consumer protection issues will do more than just address the debt itself; they will scrutinize the collector's actions for any violations of your rights. Experienced lawyers in this field handle a range of problems, from errors on credit reports and illegal harassment from debt collectors to fighting car repossessions. This background is crucial because if a collector has broken the law, it can become powerful leverage in your case, potentially leading to a reduction of the debt or even a dismissal.

Expertise in Wisconsin Debt Law

Debt laws are not one-size-fits-all; they change significantly from state to state. That's why finding a lawyer who is an expert in Wisconsin debt law is absolutely critical. A local expert will be deeply familiar with the state's statute of limitations on debt, the specific rules for wage garnishment, and all the legal defenses available to you as a resident. They’ll also understand the local court procedures and may even have experience with the attorneys on the other side. This insider knowledge can be a significant advantage, giving you a much stronger position than you’d have with an out-of-state or general practice attorney who isn't familiar with the local legal landscape.

A Proven Track Record of Success

You deserve a lawyer who has a history of achieving positive outcomes for clients in situations like yours. When you're researching potential attorneys, look for evidence of their success. This could be in the form of client testimonials, case studies, or online reviews. Some law firms, like West & Dunn, have experience representing both debtors and creditors, which gives them unique insight into the other side's strategies. During your consultation, ask directly about their experience with your specific type of debt or your particular creditor. A confident lawyer should be able to speak to their track record and explain how they've helped others in similar situations.

Clear Communication and Availability

A legal battle is confusing enough without a lawyer who speaks in jargon. You need someone who can explain your options in plain English and who makes you feel heard. Pay attention to communication style from your very first interaction. Many excellent debt defense lawyers offer a free initial consultation, which is the perfect opportunity to see if you connect. Do they listen to your story without interrupting? Do they answer your questions directly? You should leave that meeting with a clear understanding of your situation and potential next steps. A good lawyer is an accessible partner who keeps you informed and makes you feel like a priority, not just another case file.

How a Lawyer Can Protect You

When you’re facing a debt lawsuit, it can feel like you’re on your own against a powerful system. But hiring a debt defense lawyer changes the equation entirely. They become your advocate, using their legal knowledge to shield you from aggressive tactics and protect your rights. A lawyer doesn't just handle paperwork; they build a strategic defense tailored to your situation. Their first and most critical job is to prevent a default judgment, which happens when you don't respond to a lawsuit and automatically lose the case. By responding on your time, they force the debt collector to prove their claim, which is often harder than you’d think. From challenging the validity of the debt in court to negotiating a fair settlement, their expertise can make the difference between a judgment against you and a fresh start. They level the playing field, ensuring your side of the story is heard and that you get the best possible outcome.

Defending You in a Lawsuit

Receiving a court summons is intimidating, and your first instinct might be to ignore it. That’s the worst thing you can do. A lawyer can step in immediately to file a formal Answer to the lawsuit, which is a critical first step. Simply responding shows the debt collector you’re prepared to defend yourself, which can make them more willing to negotiate or even drop the case. Your attorney will scrutinize the collector’s claims, looking for weaknesses like missing paperwork or an expired statute of limitations. They will represent you in all court proceedings, so you don’t have to face a judge alone. Having a professional fight back on your behalf often surprises creditors and can lead to a much better outcome.

Negotiating with Creditors

Many debt lawsuits can be resolved before they ever reach a courtroom verdict. Lawyers are expert negotiators who can communicate with your creditors to work out a deal. This process, known as debt settlement, often involves reaching an agreement to pay a lump sum that’s less than the total amount you owe. Your attorney understands what creditors are typically willing to accept and can craft a compelling argument for why a settlement is in their best interest, too. They handle all the back-and-forth, protecting you from high-pressure tactics and ensuring any agreement is fair, properly documented, and legally binding. This can save you money and the stress of a prolonged legal battle.

Stopping Wage Garnishment

One of the most frightening consequences of a debt judgment is wage garnishment, where a creditor gets a court order to take money directly from your paycheck. If you’re facing the threat of garnishment, a lawyer can act quickly to protect your income. They will review the court order to ensure the creditor has followed every legal requirement. If there are any procedural errors, they can challenge the garnishment in court. A lawyer can also help you understand your rights and the legal limits on how much can be taken from your pay. They can explore options to stop or reduce the amount being garnished, ensuring you have enough money left to pay for your essential living expenses.

Fixing Errors on Your Credit Report

Debt collection issues and credit report errors often go hand in hand. An incorrect debt amount, a paid-off debt that’s still listed as active, or an account you don’t recognize can seriously damage your credit score. A lawyer experienced in consumer protection law can help you clean up your credit report. They know how to formally dispute inaccuracies with the credit bureaus under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). If the credit bureaus or creditors fail to correct the mistakes, your lawyer can take legal action to force them to comply and even seek damages for the harm caused to your credit. This ensures that a past debt issue doesn't unfairly follow you into the future.

Exploring Alternatives to Bankruptcy

While bankruptcy is a valid solution for some, it’s not the only way out of overwhelming debt. A good debt defense lawyer will review your complete financial picture and explain all the available options. They can help you understand the pros and cons of each path, from debt consolidation to settlement plans. Their goal is to find the most effective strategy for your specific circumstances, one that resolves your debt while minimizing long-term damage to your financial health. There are many debt relief services available, and an attorney can guide you toward the one that makes the most sense for you and your family.

Understanding Legal Fees

When you’re already dealing with debt, the thought of adding legal fees can feel overwhelming. But hiring a lawyer is an investment in protecting your financial future, and it’s often more affordable than you might think. Understanding how lawyers charge for their services will help you find the right fit for your budget and your case. Let's break down what you can expect when it comes to costs.

How Much Does a Debt Lawyer Cost?

The cost of a debt defense lawyer in Wisconsin can vary quite a bit. On average, you might see rates around $200 per hour. However, this isn't a fixed number. An attorney’s experience, reputation, and the specific details of your case all play a role. For more complex situations or highly experienced lawyers, hourly rates in Wisconsin can range from $350 to over $500. While that sounds like a lot, remember that an effective lawyer can often save you much more than their fee by getting your case dismissed or negotiating a favorable settlement.

Common Fee Arrangements

Lawyers use a few different models to bill for their services, and it’s helpful to know the difference. The most common is the hourly rate, where you pay the lawyer for the time they spend working on your case. Another popular option is a flat fee. With a flat fee, the attorney charges a single, upfront price for a specific service, like responding to a lawsuit. This gives you a predictable cost, so you know exactly what you’re paying from the start. Always ask a potential attorney which billing method they use and why it’s the best choice for your situation.

Payment Plans and Options

Don't let the initial cost keep you from seeking legal help. Many debt defense attorneys understand their clients' financial situations and offer flexible payment options. You can often arrange a payment plan that allows you to pay the legal fees over time. Wisconsin also has specific Supreme Court Rules that protect you. For instance, if you pay a flat fee, the lawyer must hold that money in a special trust account and can only withdraw funds as they complete the work on your case. This ensures they earn their fee and gives you peace of mind.

What Your Fees Cover

When you pay a lawyer, you're paying for more than just their time in a courtroom. The fees cover all the work that goes into building a strong defense for you. This includes the initial case review, legal research, and drafting and filing court documents. It also covers time spent on phone calls and emails with you, the court, and the opposing side. If your lawyer is negotiating with creditors on your behalf, that time is covered, too. Essentially, you are paying for their expertise and the comprehensive service required to handle your case from start to finish.

Watch Out for Hidden Costs

Your lawyer's fee is the main expense, but it might not be the only one. Legal cases come with other costs, like court filing fees, charges for serving legal documents to the other party, and fees for expert witnesses if needed. For example, the Wisconsin Circuit Court has an e-filing fee for submitting documents electronically. A good lawyer will be transparent about these potential extra costs from the very beginning. During your consultation, be sure to ask for a full breakdown of all anticipated expenses so you have a clear picture of the total investment.

How to Choose Your Debt Defense Attorney

Finding the right attorney can feel like a huge task, but breaking it down into manageable steps makes it much easier. You’re looking for a partner who understands your situation and has the right experience to help you. Think of this process as a series of interviews where you’re in charge. You need to find someone you trust, who communicates clearly, and who has a solid background in consumer debt cases. A good lawyer will not only represent you but also empower you with knowledge about your rights and options. Let’s walk through how to find the best legal support for your case.

Where to Start Your Research

A great place to begin your search is with law firms that focus specifically on debt settlement and consumer protection. These firms are dedicated to helping people in your exact situation. Look for attorneys who talk about their commitment to their clients, not just their legal victories. For example, some firms emphasize their goal is to help clients by negotiating with creditors to accept smaller, one-time payments. This client-first approach is a strong signal that they are dedicated to finding the best possible resolution for you. Start by searching online for "debt defense lawyers in Wisconsin" or "consumer protection attorneys near me" and explore their websites to get a feel for their philosophy.

Key Questions to Ask in a Consultation

Your initial consultation is your chance to interview a potential attorney. Don't be shy about asking direct questions to see if they're a good fit. You want someone who can explain complex legal issues in a way that makes sense to you. A good consumer protection law firm will take the time to understand your specific circumstances and lay out a clear path forward.

Here are a few key questions to ask:

• How many cases like mine have you handled?
• What is your strategy for defending against this type of lawsuit?
• How will you keep me updated on my case?
• What are the potential outcomes?
• Can you provide a clear breakdown of your fees?

Red Flags to Watch For

As you search for help, be wary of companies that make big promises that sound too good to be true. Be particularly cautious of for-profit debt settlement companies that are not law firms. Many of these businesses charge high fees for services they can't actually deliver, like legal representation in court. According to consumer advocates, it's important to understand the difference before you hire an attorney for debt settlement. A major red flag is any company that guarantees they can get your debt dismissed or pressures you to sign up immediately. A reputable attorney will give you a realistic assessment of your case, not an unrealistic guarantee.

Documents to Prepare

To make your first meeting as productive as possible, gather all the paperwork related to your debt. Having your documents organized helps the attorney get a clear picture of your situation right away. This allows them to give you more specific and useful advice during the consultation. Before you meet with any debt collections attorneys, try to collect the following items:

• The lawsuit summons and complaint
• Any letters or notices from the creditor or debt collector
• Your original loan or credit card agreements
• Statements showing your payment history
• A copy of your credit report

Don't worry if you can't find everything, but the more information you can provide, the better.

Verifying Their Credentials

Before you make a final decision, take a moment to verify the attorney's credentials. You need to be sure they are licensed and in good standing to practice law in Wisconsin. Any lawyer licensed to practice before the highest court of any state is generally eligible to handle cases in federal court in Wisconsin, but it's always good to double-check. You can typically verify an attorney's license through the State Bar of Wisconsin's website. This simple step ensures the person you're trusting with your financial future is qualified to represent you. Checking their attorney admissions status can give you peace of mind that you're in capable hands.

What to Expect in the Debt Defense Process

Once you’ve chosen a lawyer, the process of defending yourself against a debt collection lawsuit begins. It might feel intimidating, but it’s really just a series of steps. Your attorney will guide you through each phase, from the first meeting to the final resolution. Knowing what’s coming can help reduce stress and empower you to be an active participant in your own defense. The goal is to move from uncertainty to a clear, actionable plan that protects your rights and your financial well-being.

Your Initial Consultation

Your first meeting with a debt defense lawyer is a critical starting point. Think of it as a two-way interview where you both decide if it's a good fit. You’ll share the details of your situation—who is suing you, for how much, and what documents you’ve received. This is your chance to ask questions and get a feel for their communication style. The lawyer, in turn, will listen to your story to understand the basics of your case. Many firms offer a free consultation to discuss your debt, making this a no-risk opportunity to explore your options and find the right attorney for you.

Evaluating Your Case

After the initial meeting, your lawyer will take a deeper look at your case. This involves carefully reviewing all the paperwork related to the debt and the lawsuit. They’ll look for any weaknesses in the creditor’s claim, such as missing documents, incorrect amounts, or procedural errors. A good lawyer will focus on understanding your specific circumstances and explaining the legal issues in a way that’s easy to grasp. This evaluation is essential for building a defense strategy that is tailored to the unique facts of your situation and gives you the best possible chance of a positive outcome.

Developing a Winning Strategy

With a full understanding of your case, your attorney will outline a plan of action. This isn’t a one-size-fits-all approach; your strategy will depend on the strengths and weaknesses identified during the evaluation. It could involve challenging the validity of the debt, arguing that the statute of limitations has expired, or pointing out violations of consumer protection laws. Sometimes, the best strategy is to negotiate a settlement with the creditor for a lower amount. Whatever the path, the key is to be proactive. Ignoring a lawsuit is the worst thing you can do, but with a solid strategy, you can fight back effectively.

Understanding the Timeline

Legal processes have strict deadlines, and debt collection cases are no exception. In Wisconsin, creditors generally have six years to sue you for most types of unpaid debts, a rule known as the statute of limitations. This six-year clock typically starts from the date of your last payment on the account. If a collector sues you after this period has passed, you may be able to get the case dismissed. Understanding this timeline is a critical part of your defense. Your lawyer will determine if the statute of limitations applies to your case and use it to your advantage.

Your Role and Responsibilities

While your lawyer handles the legal complexities, you play a vital role in your own defense. Your main responsibilities are to be open, honest, and responsive. Provide your attorney with all requested documents and information promptly. Keep them updated on any new communications you receive from the debt collector. Legal problems can be incredibly stressful, and it’s important to lean on your lawyer’s expertise rather than trying to handle difficult matters by yourself. By working as a team, you and your attorney can build the strongest possible defense and work toward a favorable resolution.

The Impact on Your Financial Future

Dealing with a debt lawsuit feels overwhelming, but the actions you take now can set the stage for a much brighter financial future. The outcome of your case has ripple effects that touch everything from your credit score to your ability to get loans down the road. Understanding these potential impacts helps you and your lawyer build a strategy that not only addresses the immediate legal challenge but also protects your long-term financial well-being. It’s about resolving the present issue while paving the way for a fresh start.

Potential Outcomes of Your Case

When you face a debt lawsuit, the case doesn't always end in a dramatic courtroom battle. Often, a more practical solution is reached. Your lawyer might find grounds to have the case dismissed entirely. Another common outcome is debt settlement, where your attorney negotiates with the creditor on your behalf. The goal is to get them to accept a smaller, one-time payment to clear the debt for good. This can be a powerful way to resolve the lawsuit, stop the collections process, and move forward without the full weight of the original debt holding you back.

How Your Credit Score is Affected

It’s important to have realistic expectations about your credit score. Even after you successfully resolve a debt, the history of the account doesn't just disappear. Past late payments or a "charge-off"—which is when the original creditor gives up on collecting and sells the debt—will likely remain on your credit report for up to seven years. While settling a debt is much better than having a judgment against you, it won't instantly repair your credit. The good news is that resolving the account stops further negative reporting and is the first step toward rebuilding your score over time.

Long-Term Financial Benefits

Looking beyond the immediate stress, resolving a debt lawsuit has significant long-term advantages. For many people, the main goal of hiring a defense lawyer is to avoid bankruptcy, which has a much more severe and lasting impact on your financial life. Reaching a settlement can feel like a win-win; you get to clear the debt for less than you owed, and the creditor recovers at least some of their money. This resolution allows you to close a difficult chapter and begin focusing on building savings, improving your credit, and working toward future financial goals.

Strategies for Preventing Future Debt

Once you've resolved your current debt issue, the next step is to create a plan to stay on solid ground. A great resource is a non-profit credit counseling agency. These organizations can help you review your finances, create a realistic budget, and develop healthy financial habits. They can offer advice and guide you toward options like a debt management plan if needed. Learning to manage your money effectively and knowing where to turn for help early on are the best ways to prevent debt from becoming a legal problem again.

Helpful Wisconsin Debt Defense Resources

Facing a debt lawsuit can feel isolating, but you don’t have to go through it alone. Wisconsin has a network of organizations and services designed to help you understand your options and protect your rights. From free legal advice to financial counseling, these resources can provide the support you need. Knowing where to turn is the first step toward taking control of the situation. Below are some key places to start your search for assistance.

Legal Aid Organizations

If you’re worried about the cost of hiring a lawyer, legal aid organizations can be a lifeline. These groups often provide free or low-cost legal services to eligible individuals. They are staffed by attorneys and law students who are passionate about helping people with civil matters, including debt collection defense. The Consumer Law Clinic at the University of Wisconsin Law School is a great example, offering "services related to consumer debt defense, earnings/wage garnishment, and unfair debt collection." Reaching out to a local legal aid society can connect you with professionals who can review your case and explain your legal standing without the financial strain.

Consumer Protection Agencies

Consumer protection law firms and agencies focus specifically on defending individuals against unfair or deceptive business practices. This includes harassment from debt collectors, errors on your credit report, and wrongful foreclosure actions. These specialists are well-versed in the laws that protect you, like the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA). For instance, the DeLadurantey Law Firm is a Wisconsin-based firm that "helps people with consumer protection issues, including errors on credit reports, harassment from debt collectors, and foreclosure defense." Working with a lawyer who specializes in this area ensures you have an advocate who knows exactly how to challenge unlawful collection tactics and hold creditors accountable.

Financial Counseling Services

Sometimes, the best defense involves getting your finances in order. Nonprofit credit counseling agencies offer guidance on budgeting, debt management, and long-term financial planning. They can help you understand your complete financial picture and create a realistic plan to get back on track. Many offer Debt Management Programs that "help you pay off credit card debt without taking out a new loan." These counselors can work with your lenders to potentially lower your interest rates and monthly payments, making your debt more manageable and helping you avoid future legal trouble. This approach addresses the root cause of the issue, not just the lawsuit itself.

State Bar Resources

The State Bar of Wisconsin is an excellent resource for finding and verifying qualified attorneys in your area. Their lawyer referral services can connect you with a licensed attorney who has experience in consumer debt cases. You can also use their directory to check a lawyer’s credentials and ensure they are in good standing. Additionally, federal court websites provide information on which attorneys are eligible to practice in those courts. For example, the requirements for attorney admissions for the Western District of Wisconsin specify that "any lawyer licensed to practice before the highest court of any state or the District of Columbia is eligible." Using these official resources helps you find a reputable lawyer you can trust.

Related Articles

• Debt Defense Lawyer Hourly Cost in Wisconsin
• Debt Lawsuit Assistance in Wisconsin

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the absolute first thing I should do after receiving a lawsuit? The most important first step is to not panic and not ignore the papers. Your immediate priority should be to contact a debt defense attorney for a consultation. There are strict deadlines for responding to a lawsuit, and missing them can lead to an automatic loss. A lawyer can review the documents, explain your options, and ensure you file a proper response on time, which is the first move in protecting your rights.

I'm already in debt, so how can I possibly afford to hire a lawyer? This is a completely valid concern, but legal help is often more accessible than you might think. Many debt defense lawyers offer free initial consultations to review your case and discuss your options without any financial commitment. They also understand their clients' situations and frequently offer flexible fee structures, such as flat fees for specific services or payment plans, to make the cost manageable. Think of it as an investment that can save you a significant amount of money by preventing a judgment or negotiating a much lower settlement.

What are the consequences if I just ignore the lawsuit papers? Ignoring a lawsuit is the one thing you should never do. If you don't respond to the court by the deadline, the creditor can win the case automatically through something called a default judgment. Once they have that judgment, they can pursue more aggressive collection methods, like garnishing your wages, seizing funds from your bank account, or placing a lien on your property. Taking action is the only way to prevent these serious outcomes.

Will settling my debt fix my credit score immediately? Settling a debt is a huge step forward, but it's not an instant fix for your credit score. The settlement will stop any further negative reporting on the account and show it as resolved, which is much better than having an open collection or a judgment against you. However, the history of late payments or the charge-off that led to the lawsuit will likely stay on your report for several years. The best way to think of it is that settling the debt is the first, most critical step in the process of rebuilding your credit over time.

If I hire a lawyer, will I still have to go to court myself? Not necessarily. In many situations, your lawyer can handle all court appearances and communications on your behalf, especially for procedural hearings. The goal for many debt defense cases is to resolve the issue through negotiation or by challenging the lawsuit before it ever gets to a full trial. Your attorney will manage the legal process, allowing you to focus on your life without the added stress of appearing before a judge alone.